Toronto Maple Leafs 08-09: Why they have to lose, to win.

Such a ridiculous claim, but in this post-lockout NHL era, it does not seem so ludicrous.  If this new era has taught us anything, it is that in order to be triumphant, a team must build from within in order to garner success.  This rebuilding phase officially began for the Leafs in February of last season, when newly-appointed GM Cliff Fletcher stated that the team would have a new look when October came around.  Former GM John Ferguson Jr.’s misdeeds aside, GM Fletcher knew right from the get-go that a significant change would be needed.  For me, amongst many supporters, that change officially began on June 20^th of this past year. On that day, the Leafs drafted blue-chip, cant-miss prospect Luke Schenn.  With the highest draft pick the Maple Leafs have had since fan-favorite Wendel Clark was drafted first overall in 1985, they officially began this re-building phase.

Now some of you may say; the last four years have been horrendous for Leaf fans.   They have had to endure a half-decade long playoff drought; so, the Leafs must make the playoffs.  Others would say; rebuilding a team is a process, this method takes time.  This recent trend of black and white thinking has become an eternal struggle, it is an argument I have had with many followers of the Maple Leafs.  Though I do not have a dogmatic, narrow-minded view of the current Maple Leaf situation, I am inclined to agree with the latter.  Simply because while the Maple Leafs do have a myriad of future assets including but not limited to; Jiri Tlusty, Nikolai Kulemin, Justin Pogge and the newly-acquired Mikhail Grabovski, to name a few. None of these potential stars really stands out to attain the status of super-star.  Now that they have finally obtained one of these superstars in Luke Schenn, it is time to acquire someone equally as high in status and talent to launch the Maple Leafs into triumph.

Take a second to look around the league, while the most extreme example being the Pittsburgh Penguins (Crosby, Malkin, Fleury) there are many others around the league who have had high draft picks over the last few years and will surely be successful in the near future.  Perhaps the most talked about turn-around in hockey, the Chicago Blackhawks, have a dynamic duo in Jonathan Toews (3^rd overall in 06) and Patrick Kane (1^st overall in 08) to go along with their abundance of other career NHLers such as Cam Barker, Dave Bolland and Jack Skille.  The Los Angeles Kings who have been quietly stock-piling future talent for years, made there biggest splash this year with 2^nd overall pick Drew Doughty to accompany future stalwart Jack Johnson (3^rd overall in 05).  Another standout of course is Wayne Gretzky’s new and improved Phoenix Coyotes who acquired Danish prospect Mikkel Boedker (8^th overall in 08) to complement Kyle Turris (3^rd overall in 07) and Peter Mueller (8^th overall in 06). FYI: I firmly believe these aforementioned teams will be a top the NHL standings in no later than two years.

These are just mere examples of what the Leafs are now facing. But one thing is abundantly obvious; most dominant teams are built on at least two or three standout prospects.   It has been 41 years since the great city of Toronto has seen the Leafs hoist the Stanley Cup.  Is it really too much to ask to endure one more season of failure?  Personally, I do not wish for a top 10 pick, I believe it’s imperative to obtain a top 3 pick.  Wouldn’t it be nice to have the choice between mega-prospects John Tavares, Victor Hedman and Luke Schenn’s brother; Brayden, among others. The Maple Leafs have been mired in mediocrity for so many years, it has certainly become an exercise in futility.  Many Leaf followers wish for the return of Mats Sundin and for some strange reason, Maple Leaf brass is seemingly leaving the door open for his return.  The team Cliff Fletcher has fielded for the 08-09 season has hockey pundits everywhere saying that not only is this team not good enough to make the playoffs, they will be lucky to escape with the 13^th spot in the Eastern Conference.  It is almost set in stone that the Leafs are a shoe-in for another playoff mishap for the fifth consecutive year. With presumably the only bottom-feeders below them being the Garth Snow inflicted; New York Islanders and the one-pony show; Atlanta Thrashers.  So if Sundin loyalties get their wish, it is my belief that it may only move them up a mere one, maybe two spots in the standings.  Is that really what we want?  You really have to ask yourselves Leaf-fans, do you want another Nik Antropov in the 09 draft, or someone who can vault this team to Stanley Cup success? So I implore you Leaf fans, as a life-long fan myself, we must lose, really lose, to win.

Author Bio

So, for as long as I can remember, I have been an avid fan of the Toronto Maple Leafs. My father's propensity for sitting me in front of the television for a seemingly never-ending string of hockey games proved to be the mitigating factor in me bleeding blue & white. Much like my fellow Leaf bretheran, I yearn for a Stanley Cup in Toronto. After 41 years of drought, I'm thinking more and more that I will be lucky to see it in my lifetime.

» View all articles filled by Alex Fineberg.
» Subscribe to Alex Fineberg's RSS feed here.
» Visit Alex Fineberg's website at: http://

More Articles by Alex Fineberg

• 2010 Canadian Olympic Squad
• Toronto Maple Leafs: The Search for a GM
• NHL In Europe?
• John Tavares vs. Victor Hedman: Who would you pick?
• Toronto Maple Leafs 08-09: Why they have to lose, to win.